A former Management Board member of the Komenda Sugar Factory Project, Ransford Chatman Vanni-Amoah, has rubbished claims made by Alan Kyerematen over the state of the facility.
According to Mr Vanni-Amoah, the comments made by the Trade and Industry Minister are untrue.
Mr Kyerematen in an interview on Metro TV’s Good Evening Ghana on Thursday, July 7, 2022, made several comments while addressing a question on the Komenda Sugar Factory in relation to the government’s conversation with the IMF.
However, Mr Vanni-Amoah who was the Secretary to the Board described the Minister’s claims made on national television as “false statements” hence his response.
He also wondered how a minister who is on “top of his job could make claims to the effect that the NDC Government retooled the old factory.”
Find below the full response:
RESPONSE TO THE MINISTER OF TRADE AND INDUSTRY ON THE KOMENDA SUGAR FACTORY
On Thursday, July 7, 2022, the Minister of Trade and Industry, Mr. Alan Kyerematen’s prerecorded interview with Paul Adom Otchere on Good Evening Ghana was aired, in which he made some false statements when he was asked about how he would situate the Komenda Sugar Factory in the I.M.F conversation.
These false statements requires appropriate response;
Mr. Kyerematen stated that “the NDC Government took a loan of over 35 million dollars to try and retool the Osagyefo Dr. Kwame Nkrumah’s Sugar Factory”.
The truth remains, and it must be clearly stated that, the credit facility of US$35 Million from the EXIM Bank of India was used to build a brand-new state-of-the-art sugar processing plant.
The distance between the locations of the John Mahama/NDC’s Komenda Sugar Development Company Limited (KSDCL) and the Osagyefo Dr. Kwame Nkrumah’s Ghana Sugar Estates Limited (GHASEL) is about three kilometers apart. How could a minister who is on top of his job make claims to the effect that the NDC Government retooled the old factory?
He also stated that, “in the planning process of the factory, there was no provision of sugarcane on sustainable basis.”
I would like to find out from the minister if he has forgotten that a 125-acre nursery plantation was bequeathed to him? Has he forgotten that he sold the overgrown sugarcanes on the plantation to akpeteshie distillers and Mim Cashew and Agricultural Products Limited in Ahafo Mim in July 2018? This nursery plantation was meant for the sustainability of sugarcane supply.
He also falsely intimated that, “some significant number of components that would have allowed the factory to work properly were not installed.”
That statement is absolutely spurious. We bequeathed to the Akufo Addo/NPP Government a complete factory which had no technical deficit. Any serious government would not let the contractor leave without executing the specifications of the contract if Alan’s assertion is anything to go by.
He said that “the E.O.C.O conducted a forensic audit of the factory and initial report put the factory at US$16 million.” If a brand-new state-of-the-art factory should have cost US$16 million according Alan Kyerematen, why should he use US$11 million to do sandblasting and paintings of that same factory. If you convert the Cedi equivalent of these two figures, it clearly shows that the cost of renovation is higher than the supposed US$16 million he quoted.
The minister asserted that “the factory is a private company.” Ghanaians demand to know from the minister who are the shareholders of the company, because it may be sold to someone on the blindside of Ghana’s Parliament. I want to unequivocally put on record that, the Government of Ghana is the 100 percent shareholder of the Komenda Sugar Development Company Ltd which was established in 2016.
He said that “the management of the company will import raw sugar to complement the supply of sugarcane from the local farmers to operationalise the factory.”
My reliable source at the ministry of Trade and Industry has revealed that they are importing raw sugar at the cost of US$600 per ton, which is higher than the cost of imported refined sugar. As at yesterday July 11, 2022, the ICUMSA 45 which is a refined white sugar costs between US$500 and US$540 per ton, depending on which country it is imported from.
Meanwhile the minister said the raw sugar is cheaper. How could US$600 be cheaper than US$500 and US$540? This strategy is economically unwise and it would impoverish the local farmers and the youth of Central Region.
The Government of Ghana is engaging the International Monetary Fund (I.M.F) for a bailout, and the Minister of Trade and Industry who is a member of the Economic Management Team could not talk about homegrown policy which Komenda Sugar Factory is the best example. But he was proud to explain how they will import raw sugar to defeat the rationale behind the establishment of the sugar factory as an import substitute.
RANSFORD CHATMAN VANNI-AMOAH
(FORMER MEMBER/SECRETARY – KOMENDA SUGAR PROJECT MANAGEMENT BOARD)